I'm not at all surprised to learn that points redemption, as a feature of your program was last in preference, and that guaranteed upgrades was the most desired.
To be perfectly straightforward and honest, I have a very different perspective on loyalty programs than most in my profession. With few exceptions, the vast majority of loyalty programs are neither strategically differentiating for the sponsor nor are they effective at rewarding a supplier's best customers. Continuing my straightforward mode, they are usually me-too, cookie-cutter variations of the reward programs that have gone before them. Points programs were more effective years ago, when there were fewer of them and they had more individuality; but, these days, they tend to be complex and bothersome, where people want simplicity. Worse, as noted, they tend to look alike, creating little additional loyalty for the sponsor.
Loyalty programs, to really optimize share of wallet for a supplier, should embrace all desired benefits/solutions a customer receives, both tangible and intangible. In other words, loyalty can be drawn from everything that contributes to perceived value with the experience. Besides Ritz-Carlton in the lodging industry, the best industry 'loyalty' program I've seen is Wyndham ByRequest. It's clearly well researched. There are no points on this program, but it has:
- Room personalization, driven by a detailed customer profile
- Opportunity to earn miles at any rate on ten participating airlines
- Free 800 calls (I just stayed at a luxury hotel this past weekend while working with a client, and each of my 800 calls to my long distance provider cost $2.00. Wow!)
- Free high-speed Internet access (My laptop has Ethernet capabilities, so I really appreciate this)
- Best available room at check-in
- Express check-in
- Dedicated phone support
- ByRequest manager at each hotel
- Membership offers, such as low package rates at Wyndham resorts
- Review stay history on-line
Whenever I have a choice, I now prefer to stay at a Wyndham. My suggestion is to look, as well, outside the industry for innovation. One example is the Aloha Club of Chart House Restaurants. In addition to other benefits, Chart House has differentiated the program by offering an around the world trip for two for anyone who dines at all their restaurants. So far, several dozen patrons have done so, giving Chart House an incredible amount of free publicity, and attracting many new members for their club program.
Dig Deeper on Customer loyalty and retention
Related Q&A from Michael Lowenstein, VP and Senior Consultant, Customer Loyalty Management, Harris Interactive
Find out if luxury retail stores should offer loyalty programs for their customers in this tip. Learn how some luxury retail brands build loyal ...continue reading
Get an experts take on raising the hurdle rates of a customer loyalty program and learn more about value-added benefits from Michael Lowenstein.continue reading
Learn a few ways to measure customer loyalty and find out about customer spend or "share of wallet," which expert Michael Lowenstein believes to be ...continue reading
Have a question for an expert?
Please add a title for your question
Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.